- Sociology of Diagnosis, Medical Anthropology, Sociology of Health and Illness, Medical Sociology, Medically Unexplained Symptoms, History of Science and Technology, and 20 moreSocial Studies Of Science, History of Psychiatry, Psychiatric nosology, Philosophy of Psychiatry (Philosophy), DSM-V, Philosophy of Psychiatry, Psychotropics, Benzodiazepines, Pharmacoepidemiology, Social emotions, Sociology of Emotion, Social Suffering, Ian Hacking, Wissenschaftsgeschichte, Life-Style Drugs, Cognitive Enhancement, Psychiatry, Psychiatry and Psychopathology, Social Suffering and Structural Injustice, and Paul Beatriz Preciadoedit
Research Interests:
Este artigo visa situar o conceito de medicalização na obra de Michel Foucault para pensar sua utilidade teórica na análise deste fenômeno. Partimos da hipótese de que a medicalização envolve dois sentidos para o autor: um relacionado à... more
Este artigo visa situar o conceito de medicalização na obra de Michel Foucault para pensar sua utilidade teórica na análise deste fenômeno. Partimos da hipótese
de que a medicalização envolve dois sentidos para o autor: um relacionado
à medicina como prática social que
passa do Estado à população; e outro relacionado ao fenômeno da medicalização indefinida, ou seja, da impossibilidade
de se produzirem práticas corporais fora
do alcance da medicina. Em seguida, trataremos da medicalização inserida no campo do biopoder contemporâneo, que tem uma nova configuração a partir da emergência da noção de risco e das novas biotecnologias. Por fim, apresentaremos
a posição do filósofo frente aos seus contemporâneos, a fim de situá-lo historicamente e mostrar como sua teoria se aproxima e se distancia do debate em torno da medicalização nos anos de 1970.
de que a medicalização envolve dois sentidos para o autor: um relacionado
à medicina como prática social que
passa do Estado à população; e outro relacionado ao fenômeno da medicalização indefinida, ou seja, da impossibilidade
de se produzirem práticas corporais fora
do alcance da medicina. Em seguida, trataremos da medicalização inserida no campo do biopoder contemporâneo, que tem uma nova configuração a partir da emergência da noção de risco e das novas biotecnologias. Por fim, apresentaremos
a posição do filósofo frente aos seus contemporâneos, a fim de situá-lo historicamente e mostrar como sua teoria se aproxima e se distancia do debate em torno da medicalização nos anos de 1970.
Research Interests:
Research Interests: Pharmacology and Anvisa
The article aims to analyze the persuasiveness of medical images using as examples two specific cases: the use of mental picture of European medicine in the late nineteenth century, and of neuroimaging in the field of contemporary... more
The article aims to analyze the persuasiveness of medical images using as examples two specific cases: the use of mental picture of European medicine in the late nineteenth century, and of neuroimaging in the field of contemporary neuroscience. The commonality between the two cases studied is the power of convincing portrayal of the supposed reality of behaviors or pathological conditions, especially in the field of mental medicine. We will emphasize the field of neuroimaging, mapping a critical analysis of the peculiarities of its production process, particularly by researchers in the neurosciences.
The article analyzes a number of conditions that allowed the brain to become established as an etiological hypothesis in the case of chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS), together with other hypotheses related to organic causes, such as viruses... more
The article analyzes a number of conditions that allowed the brain to become established as an etiological hypothesis in the case of chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS), together with other hypotheses related to organic causes, such as viruses and immunity. It also addresses the process of cerebralization of personhood, which grew out of the use of neuroimaging for research and diagnostic purposes and according to which the brain constitutes the prime place for looking for the cause of the diseases - including CFS - within the context of a somatic culture, intensified at the end of the twentieth century.
This article examines the pertinence of the concept of medicalization for socio-cultural analysis. The study is based on the criticism which emerged in the international literature between 2000 and 2010. The criticism stressed the... more
This article examines the pertinence of the concept of medicalization for socio-cultural analysis. The study is based on the criticism which emerged in the international literature between 2000 and 2010. The criticism stressed the excessive generality of the expression that encompasses different situations and thereby loses its analytical precision. The main meanings of the term medicalization are examined, namely 1) the major strategies of hygienization of the population; 2) the transformation of behavior considered deviant into disorders; 3) control strategies and the medical imperative; 4) the participation of non-medical actors. Based on the different meanings of the notion of medicalization, the transient nature of the concept needs to be stressed, i.e. the need to specify the different meanings attributed to the notion depending on the different contexts in which it is used. If this is not done, the concept will lose its theoretical accuracy and will possibly no longer be useful for social analysis.
Abstract The article addresses the medical category of neurasthenia, developed in the United States by neurologist George Beard at the close of the nineteenth century. Points of discussion include the principle features of the... more
Abstract
The article addresses the medical category of
neurasthenia, developed in the United States
by neurologist George Beard at the close of
the nineteenth century. Points of discussion
include the principle features of the
category’s clinical presentation, the main
hypotheses advanced to account for
symptoms, and the treatment alternatives
suggested in Beard’s works. The article also
looks at how the diagnosis was received
outside the United States, both in Europe
and, more specifically, in Brazil.
Keywords: neurasthenia; George Beard
(1839-1883); mental medicine; Brazil
The article addresses the medical category of
neurasthenia, developed in the United States
by neurologist George Beard at the close of
the nineteenth century. Points of discussion
include the principle features of the
category’s clinical presentation, the main
hypotheses advanced to account for
symptoms, and the treatment alternatives
suggested in Beard’s works. The article also
looks at how the diagnosis was received
outside the United States, both in Europe
and, more specifically, in Brazil.
Keywords: neurasthenia; George Beard
(1839-1883); mental medicine; Brazil
The article analyzes the medical category of psychasthenia, used by French psychiatry from the late nineteenth through the early twentieth centuries. It describes the clinical profile of psychasthenia and the main hypotheses meant to... more
The article analyzes the medical category of
psychasthenia, used by French psychiatry
from the late nineteenth through the early
twentieth centuries. It describes the clinical
profile of psychasthenia and the main
hypotheses meant to account for symptoms
as defined and advanced by Pierre Janet, the
central figure in systematization of this
category. The article also looks at how this
diagnosis was used in Brazil and how it
related to the profile of neurasthenia within
the context of Brazilian psychiatry.
Keywords: psychasthenia; Pierre Janet
(1859-1947); psychiatry; Brazil
psychasthenia, used by French psychiatry
from the late nineteenth through the early
twentieth centuries. It describes the clinical
profile of psychasthenia and the main
hypotheses meant to account for symptoms
as defined and advanced by Pierre Janet, the
central figure in systematization of this
category. The article also looks at how this
diagnosis was used in Brazil and how it
related to the profile of neurasthenia within
the context of Brazilian psychiatry.
Keywords: psychasthenia; Pierre Janet
(1859-1947); psychiatry; Brazil
This paper analyses the conditions present for the emergence of the talking cure as one among other medical therapies in the late 19th century. The hypothesis is that the construction of the psychism as a medical object is related to the... more
This paper analyses the conditions present for the emergence of the talking cure as one among other medical therapies in the late 19th century. The hypothesis is that the construction of the psychism as a medical object is related to the emergence of medical categories for symptoms that seem to have no anatomical basis, such as neurasthenia, hysteria and psychosthenia. These categories helped show that purely organic explanations were insufficient to explain many symptoms. They therefore contributed to the establishment up a new style of clinical treatment based on speech.
Key words: Talking cure, mental medicine, medical categories
Key words: Talking cure, mental medicine, medical categories
Chronic Fatigue Syndrome has emerged in the end of 1980, in developed countries as United States, Canada and United Kingdom. We aim to present the chronic fatigue syndrome in the context of other functional syndromes. We intend to... more
Chronic Fatigue Syndrome has emerged in the end of 1980, in developed countries as United States, Canada and United Kingdom. We aim to present the chronic fatigue syndrome in the context of other functional syndromes. We intend to analyze its symptoms, and the remarkable absence of an anatomophysiological finding related to this condition. We will discuss, since the distinction between somatic and mental disease, the legitimacy/illegitimacy effects suffered by the chronic fatigue syndrome patient. We will analyze the patient reaction of searching for a somatic explanation to the disease, as a way to turn the chronic fatigue syndrome into a reliable condition, and as a way of avoiding associations with psychosomatic diseases.
Research Interests:
Analisa alguns dos elementos sociohistóricos que configuraram condições de possibilidade para a emergência da neurastenia como categoria nosológica, na segunda metade do século XIX, bem como os aspectos que influenciaram seu declínio em... more
Analisa alguns dos elementos sociohistóricos que configuraram condições de possibilidade para a emergência da neurastenia como categoria nosológica, na segunda metade do século XIX, bem como os aspectos que influenciaram seu declínio em meios médicos e leigos. Propõe breve apresentação dessa categoria médica e discussão mais detalhada sobre alguns debates em que ela encontra sustentação, tais como a ideia do desgaste do suprimento nervoso, os estudos e as preocupações novecentistas sobre a fadiga e a pressuposição da somatogênese da doença. Analisa, por fim, o processo de declínio da categoria ressaltando alguns elementos que alteraram seu estatuto e sua utilidade como diagnóstico.
Research Interests: Fatigue and Neurasthenia
This article presents the medical category of neurasthenia and its etiological hypotheses in the medical writings of George Beard and other European writers who were his contemporaries. We present the main features and symptoms of... more
This article presents the medical category of neurasthenia and its etiological hypotheses in the medical writings of George Beard and other European writers who were his contemporaries. We present the main features and symptoms of neurasthenia and an overview of the etiological hypothesis attributed to the disease at that time, that is: the American civilization in the late 19th century, nervous diathesis and the concept of functional lesions of the nervous system.
Key words: Neurasthenia, civilization, functional lesion, hereditary factors
Key words: Neurasthenia, civilization, functional lesion, hereditary factors
Research Interests:
This paper presents the historical evolution of medical diagnosis related to diseases without lesions. We focus on this problematic field of history of medicine observing the difficulties to get clinical evidences using pattern... more
This paper presents the historical evolution of medical diagnosis related to diseases without lesions. We focus on this problematic field of history of medicine observing the difficulties to get clinical evidences using pattern procedures. We approach the nosological classifications for these diseases during the 19th century based on three paradigms: irritability, arc-reflex, central nervous system. During the 20th century, we focus on the psychogenetic paradigm and on the transformations that those diagnosis have had in the different editions of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. Finally, we approach some of the new names that diseases without lesions have achieved nowadays, taking functional somatic syndromes as a contemporary example and analyzing the (i)legitimacy dilemma that surround that kind of illnesses.
Abstract This article analyzes the use of neuroimaging in research into chronic fatigue syndrome. It reviews some works published in the 1990s and investigates a specific aspect of these studies, namely the search for a cerebral... more
Abstract This article analyzes the use of neuroimaging
in research into chronic fatigue syndrome.
It reviews some works published in the
1990s and investigates a specific aspect of these
studies, namely the search for a cerebral abnormality,
in the form of an altered activation pattern,
which could provide a pattern for diagnosis
and treatment of the disease. The understanding
of chronic fatigue syndrome as a disease reduced
to some cerebral findings is analyzed, arguing in
favor of a broader vision of this disease that includes
psychosocial elements of the patient’s life as
opposed to entirely somatic explanations.
Key words Chronic fatigue syndrome, Psychosocial
factors, Neuroimaging
in research into chronic fatigue syndrome.
It reviews some works published in the
1990s and investigates a specific aspect of these
studies, namely the search for a cerebral abnormality,
in the form of an altered activation pattern,
which could provide a pattern for diagnosis
and treatment of the disease. The understanding
of chronic fatigue syndrome as a disease reduced
to some cerebral findings is analyzed, arguing in
favor of a broader vision of this disease that includes
psychosocial elements of the patient’s life as
opposed to entirely somatic explanations.
Key words Chronic fatigue syndrome, Psychosocial
factors, Neuroimaging
In this paper we intend to present and discuss some metaphors of the human brain present in a sample of materials of science communication aimed, therefore, to reflect on meanings and uses associated with the human brain. In the case of... more
In this paper we intend to present and discuss some metaphors of the human brain present in a sample of materials of science communication aimed, therefore, to reflect on meanings and uses associated with the human brain. In the case of the scientific dissemination, in which scientists and science journalists seek to translate or recreate to the lay public the scientific knowledge, the importance of metaphors is evident as they approach the lay public of certain meanings attributed by the promoters of science on the functioning of the brain. Finally, we analytically discuss a few points of contact between the metaphors found.
Key words: metaphors; brain; neurosciences; scientific dissemination
Key words: metaphors; brain; neurosciences; scientific dissemination
Resumo Clínicos alternam constantemente o foco de sua atenção quando se deparam com um paciente que apresenta fenômenos psicopatológicos. Seguramente, não é possível determinar de antemão (ou seja, até que se passe algum tempo do processo... more
Resumo Clínicos alternam constantemente o foco de sua atenção quando se deparam com um paciente que apresenta fenômenos psicopatológicos. Seguramente, não é possível determinar de antemão (ou seja, até que se passe algum tempo do processo de avaliação diagnóstica) onde reside o problema, se é necessário operar um zoom in e investigar o cérebro do paciente (ou os genes), ou operar um zoom out e prestar atenção especial a seu mundo relacional (ou social), ou, ainda, se devemos nos concentrar em sua própria experiência subjetiva. Em psiquiatria, lidamos com sujeitos corporais e suas ações, tal como descritas dentro de um contexto, não meramente com disfunções de partes do corpo. No entanto, se rejeitamos o reducionismo, isto é, a ideia de que há um nível explicativo único e fundamental para todos os transtornos mentais, e adotamos, em vez disso, um modelo multinível dentro de uma posição explanatória pluralista, permanecerá indeterminado se tais mudanças nos níveis explanatórios que ocorrem na prática clínica cotidiana podem ou não ser inteiramente codificadas ou, em outras palavras, em que medida essas mudanças se apoiam, inevitavelmente, em um conhecimento tácito. Se esse é o caso, não seria possível codificar o julgamento clínico em algoritmos, mesmo que muito sofisticados. Abstract Clinicians constantly shift the focus of their attention when seeing a patient who presents psychopathological phenomena. Arguably, it is not possible to tell in advance (that is, before quite a while in the diagnostic assessment process) where the problem lies, whether it is necessary to zoom in and look into the patient's brain (or genes), or if we have to zoom out and pay special attention to his/her relational (or social) world, or if we should concentrate on his/her own subjective experience. In psychiatry, we deal with embodied subjects and their actions under description and within context, not merely bodily dysfunctions. However, if we reject
Research Interests:
ZORZANELLI, R. T. ; VERZTMAN, Julio . O pavor do rubor: a emergência da timidez na medicina mental francesa do século XIX. In: HERZOG, R.;PACHECO-FERREIRA,F;PINHEIRO, T.;VERZTMAN, J.. (Org.). Sofrimentos Narcísicos. Sofrimentos Narcísicos. Rio de Janeiro: Companhia de Freud, 2012, v. , p. 01-15. more
